Dalil at-tamanu’ (proof of the mutual contradiction of two hypothetical Gods) in works of early and later Muslim theologians
Download PDF-file
Abstract
The belief of a person is a very important part in his life, it is one of the pillars of the religion of Islam, in which a Muslim lives from birth until death and even after death. The unity of God is one of his qualities, and in order to establish His Unity, convincing evidence is needed, and one of them dalil at-tamanu. This is a rational proof, which is based on the verse: Had there been therein (in the heavens and the earth) gods besides Allah, then verily both would have been ruined. In the first section, I gave a lexical and terminological definition for dalil at-tamanu, and in the second section, I explained the reliance of predecessors and also modern scholars on dalil attamanu. At the end of the article, I have summed up that will be useful for anyone who wants to specialize in this science.
For citation
Gadzhidadaev M.R. Dalil at-tamanu’ (proof of the mutual contradiction of two hypothetical Gods) in works of early and later Muslim theologians // Bulletin of the Bolgar Islamic Academy. .3 № .3202.
References
1. Muslim ibn Hajaj al-naysaburi, kitab al-iman, bab man lakiya Allahu bi al-iman ya huva gayr shak fihi dahala al-janna va haruma ala al-nar, Sahih Muslim, Beirut, dar ihya al-turas al-arabi. T. 5. р. 2938
2. Abu Nasr Ismail bin Hammad al-Javhari al-Farabi, as-sihah taj al-lugati va sihah al-arabiyati, darul ilm lilmlayin, Beirut, fourth edition - 1987, T.6. р. 2563
3. Murtaza az-Zabidi, Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Abd ar-Razzak al-Huseyni, Taj al-arus min jawahir al-qamus, darul-Hidayat, T.40. р. 603
4. Abu al-Baqa Ayub bin Musa al-Huseyni al-Qarimi al-Hanafi, al-Kulliyatu mujam fil-mustalahati, wal-furuqi al-lugawiyya, Beirut, Muassasa arRisala. р. 1083
5. Al-Qazi Abd an-Nabi bin abd-Rasul al-Ahmad Nakri, dustur al-ulama, Beirut, darul kutub al-ilmiyya, first edition 1421-2000, T.4 р. 292
6. Abu Mansur al-Maturidi, Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Mahmud, tafsir al-Maturidi, darul kutub al-ilmiyya, Beirut, first edition, 1426-2005, T.10. р. 603
7. Doctor Said Abdu-latif fuda, hashiyat ala khamsuna fi usuli-ddini, alaslein li-dirasati wa-nnashr, first edition, 1438-2017. р. 245
8. Wahba bin Mustafa az-Zuhayli ad-Dimashqi,at-Tafsir al-Munir fil-aqida wa-sharia wal-manhaj, Damask, Darul-fikr, tenth edition, 1430-2009, T.15. р. 325
9. Doctor Muhammad Said Ramadan al-Buti, Kubra al-yaqiniyya alkawniyya, Darul-fikr, 1440-2019. р. 392
10. Muhammad Mutawalli ash-Sha’rawi, Khawatir Imaniyya, Cairo, dar anNur, T.20 р. 11553
2. Abu Nasr Ismail bin Hammad al-Javhari al-Farabi, as-sihah taj al-lugati va sihah al-arabiyati, darul ilm lilmlayin, Beirut, fourth edition - 1987, T.6. р. 2563
3. Murtaza az-Zabidi, Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Abd ar-Razzak al-Huseyni, Taj al-arus min jawahir al-qamus, darul-Hidayat, T.40. р. 603
4. Abu al-Baqa Ayub bin Musa al-Huseyni al-Qarimi al-Hanafi, al-Kulliyatu mujam fil-mustalahati, wal-furuqi al-lugawiyya, Beirut, Muassasa arRisala. р. 1083
5. Al-Qazi Abd an-Nabi bin abd-Rasul al-Ahmad Nakri, dustur al-ulama, Beirut, darul kutub al-ilmiyya, first edition 1421-2000, T.4 р. 292
6. Abu Mansur al-Maturidi, Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Mahmud, tafsir al-Maturidi, darul kutub al-ilmiyya, Beirut, first edition, 1426-2005, T.10. р. 603
7. Doctor Said Abdu-latif fuda, hashiyat ala khamsuna fi usuli-ddini, alaslein li-dirasati wa-nnashr, first edition, 1438-2017. р. 245
8. Wahba bin Mustafa az-Zuhayli ad-Dimashqi,at-Tafsir al-Munir fil-aqida wa-sharia wal-manhaj, Damask, Darul-fikr, tenth edition, 1430-2009, T.15. р. 325
9. Doctor Muhammad Said Ramadan al-Buti, Kubra al-yaqiniyya alkawniyya, Darul-fikr, 1440-2019. р. 392
10. Muhammad Mutawalli ash-Sha’rawi, Khawatir Imaniyya, Cairo, dar anNur, T.20 р. 11553