Imam al-Qurtubiʼs position on the sinlessness of the prophets
Abstract
This article discusses the concept of sinlessness and its relation to the prophets and messengers of Allah Almighty. Sinlessness is a special quality inherent only in prophets and messengers, as they were sent down by Allah to teach religion, and even the slightest sin committed by them can undermine the foundations of religion. And this article also discusses the different points of view on this issue, and the arguments of each side. And it is explained that sins are divided into two kinds: major sins, such as joining a fellow believer to God, killing an innocent person, adultery, etc. Minor sins are divided into two kinds: those that are considered low and despicable so that the one who committed them is considered despicable and low, and those that are not. It proves the untenability and inadmissibility of following the opinion of some scholars who said that the prophets are sinless only with regard to big sins and small mean sins, and committing small sins is permissible and it does not diminish their dignity. The truth of the opinion that prophets are protected from all kinds of sins big and small is proved. But all of them are unanimous that Prophets do not commit big sins and mean small sins. In this article we will explore the vision of Imam Abu Abdullah Muhammad bin Ahmad Shams al-Din al-Qurtubi al-Maliki on this issue.
For citation
Kotiev A.M. Imam al-Qurtubiʼs position on the sinlessness of the prophets // Bulletin of the Bоlgar Islamic Academy, 2024, no 1, рр. 48–56.
References
1. Ibn Abidin. Xashiyat radd al muhtar, durr al muhtar: sharh tanwir al absar. Beirut, 1966. (In Arabic)
2. Ibn Manzur. Lisan al arab. Beirut, 1993. (In Arabic)
3. Abu Isa at Tirmizi. Al jamig al kabir. Beirut, 1996. (In Arabic)
4. Ahmad bin Ali bin al Musni at Tamimi. Musnad Abi Yagla al Musili. Cairo, 2013. (In Arabic)
5. Ahmad Muhtar abd al Hamid. Mugjamy al Lugaty al Arabiyat al Mugasirat. 2008. (In Arabic)
6. Hamza Muhammad Kasim. Manar al Kari sharh Muhtasar Sahih al Buhari. Damascus, 1990. (In Arabic)
7. Hair ad Dinbin Faris, az Zirikli ad Dimashki. Aglamy li Zirikli. Beirut, 2002. (In Arabic)
8. An Nasai. Sunan an Nasai. Cairo, 1930. (In Arabic)
9. Koran Surat al Bakara. (In Arabic)
10. Majalla “Din ya Magishat”. Kazan, 1910. (In Arabic)
11. Muhammad ar Ramzi. Talfik al Ahbar ya talkih al Asar. Beirut; Lubnan, 2002. (In Arabic)
12. Muhammad bin Ali al Haskafi. Dur al Muhtar sharh Tanwir al Absar ya Jamig al Bihar. (In Arabic)
13. Muhammad Gabid as Sindi. Tawalig al Anwar sharh Dur al Muhtar. Beirut; Lubnan, 2003. (In Arabic)
2. Ibn Manzur. Lisan al arab. Beirut, 1993. (In Arabic)
3. Abu Isa at Tirmizi. Al jamig al kabir. Beirut, 1996. (In Arabic)
4. Ahmad bin Ali bin al Musni at Tamimi. Musnad Abi Yagla al Musili. Cairo, 2013. (In Arabic)
5. Ahmad Muhtar abd al Hamid. Mugjamy al Lugaty al Arabiyat al Mugasirat. 2008. (In Arabic)
6. Hamza Muhammad Kasim. Manar al Kari sharh Muhtasar Sahih al Buhari. Damascus, 1990. (In Arabic)
7. Hair ad Dinbin Faris, az Zirikli ad Dimashki. Aglamy li Zirikli. Beirut, 2002. (In Arabic)
8. An Nasai. Sunan an Nasai. Cairo, 1930. (In Arabic)
9. Koran Surat al Bakara. (In Arabic)
10. Majalla “Din ya Magishat”. Kazan, 1910. (In Arabic)
11. Muhammad ar Ramzi. Talfik al Ahbar ya talkih al Asar. Beirut; Lubnan, 2002. (In Arabic)
12. Muhammad bin Ali al Haskafi. Dur al Muhtar sharh Tanwir al Absar ya Jamig al Bihar. (In Arabic)
13. Muhammad Gabid as Sindi. Tawalig al Anwar sharh Dur al Muhtar. Beirut; Lubnan, 2003. (In Arabic)
