Comparative analysis between the fatwas of al-Shamgudi and al-Ramli on the issue of atonement for sins in hajj
Download PDF-file
Abstract
This article is devoted to a comparative analysis of the fatwas of Imam al-Ramli and Imam al-Shamgudi on the issue of performing hajj to atone for sins. The study focuses on comparing the points of view and interpretations presented in these two fatwas and analyzes how they can be understood in the context of Islamic theology and practice. The hadiths of the Prophet Muhammad, the opinions of such scholars as Suleiman al-Jamal, Ibrahim al-Bajuri, Kirmini are given. A comparative analysis of the fatwas of Imam al-Ramli and Imam al-Shamgudi allows us to understand the similarities and differences in interpretations and approaches to this topic and how these fatwas can affect believersʼ understanding of atonement and forgiveness of sins in Islam.
For citation
Kurbanov G.A., Shakhrudinov M.I. Comparative analysis between the fatwas of al-Shamgudi and al-Ramli on the issue of atonement for sins in hajj // Bulletin of the Bolgar Islamic Academy, 2024, no. 3 (7), рр. 86–94.
References
1. Zainudin Muhammad. At-tavqifu ala muhimmati at-taarif. Cairo, 1990, p. 108. (in Arabic)
2. Ahmad bin Muhammad Ali bin hajar al-Haitami. Tuhfat al-muhtaj fi sharhi al-manhaj va havashi al-shirvani va al-ubadi. Dar almaktabati al-tjariyati al-kubra. Cairo, 1983, vol. 4, p. 2. (in Arabic)
3. Al-fikhu al-manhaj ala mathhabi al-imami al- Shafii. Damask, 1992, vol. 2, p. 113. (in Arabic)
4. Abu Ibrahim Ishaq bin Ibrahim bin Al-Hussein al-Farabi. Mu‘Jam diwan al-Adab. Cairo, 2003, vol. 1, p. 251. (in Arabic)
5. Ahmad bin Muhammad Ali bin hajar ai-Haitami. Al-fatava al-kubra al-fikhiya. Beyrut – Lubnan, 2008, vol. 2, p. 99. (in Arabic)
6. Suleiman bin Umar bin Mansur al–ajily. Hashiyat al-Jamal ala sharhi manhaj. Beyrut – Lubnan, 1996, vol. 4, p. 4. (in Arabic)
7. Ibrahim bin Muhammad bin Ahmad al-misry al-Shafii al-Bajury. Hashiyatu al-Bajuri ala sharhi ibn Qasim al-Ghazi ala matni abi Shuja. Jidda, 2016, vol. 2, p. 477. (in Arabic)
8. Al-imam Ahmad bin Hanbal. Musnad al-imam Ahmad bin Hanbal. Muasasatu al-risalati, 2001, vol. 16, p. 192, no. 10274. (in Arabic)
9. Abu-bakr Ahmad bin Amr bin Abdulhaliq bin Hallad bin Ubaidullah al-Atky. Musnad al-Bazzar. Maktabat al-ulumi va al-hikam. Munavvara, 2009, nо. 6177. (in Arabic)
10. Abu-bakr Ahmad bin al-Husain bin Ali al-Baihaqi. As-Sunan alkubra. Beyrut – Lubnan, 2003, nо. 9481. (in Arabic)
11. Muhammad bin Yusuf bin Ali bin said Shamsu ad din al-Kirmany. Al Kavakibu ad-durar fi sharh sahih al-Buhary. Beyrut – Lubnan, 1981, vol. 9, p. 3. (in Arabic)
12. Abu Abdillah Muhammad bin Ismail al-Buhary al-jafary. Sahih alBuhary. Damask, 1993, nо. 38. (in Arabic)
13. Abdu ar-Rahman bin abi Bakr Jalal ad-din as-Suyuty. Jamiul ahadis, nо. 22014. (in Arabic)
14. Sahih ai-Buhary. Nо. 6492. (in Arabic)
15. Musnad imam ai-Ahmad. Nо. 8715. (in Arabic)
2. Ahmad bin Muhammad Ali bin hajar al-Haitami. Tuhfat al-muhtaj fi sharhi al-manhaj va havashi al-shirvani va al-ubadi. Dar almaktabati al-tjariyati al-kubra. Cairo, 1983, vol. 4, p. 2. (in Arabic)
3. Al-fikhu al-manhaj ala mathhabi al-imami al- Shafii. Damask, 1992, vol. 2, p. 113. (in Arabic)
4. Abu Ibrahim Ishaq bin Ibrahim bin Al-Hussein al-Farabi. Mu‘Jam diwan al-Adab. Cairo, 2003, vol. 1, p. 251. (in Arabic)
5. Ahmad bin Muhammad Ali bin hajar ai-Haitami. Al-fatava al-kubra al-fikhiya. Beyrut – Lubnan, 2008, vol. 2, p. 99. (in Arabic)
6. Suleiman bin Umar bin Mansur al–ajily. Hashiyat al-Jamal ala sharhi manhaj. Beyrut – Lubnan, 1996, vol. 4, p. 4. (in Arabic)
7. Ibrahim bin Muhammad bin Ahmad al-misry al-Shafii al-Bajury. Hashiyatu al-Bajuri ala sharhi ibn Qasim al-Ghazi ala matni abi Shuja. Jidda, 2016, vol. 2, p. 477. (in Arabic)
8. Al-imam Ahmad bin Hanbal. Musnad al-imam Ahmad bin Hanbal. Muasasatu al-risalati, 2001, vol. 16, p. 192, no. 10274. (in Arabic)
9. Abu-bakr Ahmad bin Amr bin Abdulhaliq bin Hallad bin Ubaidullah al-Atky. Musnad al-Bazzar. Maktabat al-ulumi va al-hikam. Munavvara, 2009, nо. 6177. (in Arabic)
10. Abu-bakr Ahmad bin al-Husain bin Ali al-Baihaqi. As-Sunan alkubra. Beyrut – Lubnan, 2003, nо. 9481. (in Arabic)
11. Muhammad bin Yusuf bin Ali bin said Shamsu ad din al-Kirmany. Al Kavakibu ad-durar fi sharh sahih al-Buhary. Beyrut – Lubnan, 1981, vol. 9, p. 3. (in Arabic)
12. Abu Abdillah Muhammad bin Ismail al-Buhary al-jafary. Sahih alBuhary. Damask, 1993, nо. 38. (in Arabic)
13. Abdu ar-Rahman bin abi Bakr Jalal ad-din as-Suyuty. Jamiul ahadis, nо. 22014. (in Arabic)
14. Sahih ai-Buhary. Nо. 6492. (in Arabic)
15. Musnad imam ai-Ahmad. Nо. 8715. (in Arabic)